Resources

Shock vs Arc Flash:
Do You Know the Difference?

WIN_20200513_11_22_30_Pro

Bobby Lindsey

President

When I conduct electrical safety classes, the first question I ask the class is this: “Show of hands. How many of you have been shocked?”  Hands immediately go up for 90 to 95% of participants. When I ask the same question about arc flash, only about 10 to 15% of participants raise their hands. With arc flash, I often see several hands go halfway up because the person is not sure whether they have been in an arc flash event. Many people who work around live electricity are not completely sure what arc flash is and how it is different from shock. Let’s clear up the confusion.

bigstock Rear-view-of-diverse-business--288064870

Electrical Hazards

Two major categories of hazards exist in the electrical environment:

Electric Shock

Shock occurs when current runs through a person’s body or on the surface of the skin. When someone is shocked, they become part of the circuit. The severity depends on the amount of current and the path the current takes through the body. Severe shock can result in ventricular fibrillation, internal burns to organs, external burns to skin, and even death, which is known as electrocution. Ventricular fibrillation can be caused by only 0.2 amps for one second.

Arc Flash

Note: Technically arc flash and arc blast are categorized separately in NFPA 70E. However, these two events often happen simultaneously and go hand in hand as a two-step process: first the flash, then the blast. An arc flash can occur without an arc blast, but it would be rare to have an arc blast without first seeing an arc flash. To simplify the content, both events will be referred to as an arc flash event in this article.

Arc Flash and electric shock are very different. In an arc flash event, the person does not become part of the circuit. The danger lies with being at ground zero of a hot and violent electrical explosion. In an arc flash event, air is the conductor of electricity. For many reasons, air can become ionized enough to conduct electricity causing an arc that short circuits between phases or between phase and ground. This results in a heated wave of plasma that can quickly reach temperatures up to 35,000 degrees Fahrenheit. To put that in perspective, the surface of the sun is about 10,000 degrees Fahrenheit.

When temperatures reach these levels, every known material on earth is vaporized, including copper conductors. When copper transforms from solid to vapor, it expands by 67,000 times. This can happen in a fraction of a second in an arc flash event. The rapid expansion leads to a tremendous dissipation of energy. The pressure from 100kA arc can reach 400 lb.ft2 of pressure, which is ten times the wind resistance typical walls are rated to withstand. In many cases, an arc flash event is similar to a bomb detonation with the worker being at ground zero.

Protection from Shock versus Protection from Arc Flash

As you have learned, shock and arc flash are different in many ways. As a result, different types of protection are required in the form of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE). Shock PPE consists mainly of insulating equipment in the form of rubber material that is voltage rated. Voltage-rated gloves and insulated tools are the most common PPE used to protect a worker from shock, although many other types of equipment may apply depending on the task.

Arc Flash protection is mainly focused on protecting a worker from a massive amount of heat. Remember, an arc flash can reach temperatures in the tens of thousands of degrees. PPE for arc flash is designed to protect a worker from severe burns, UV light, and very loud sound. Arc flash PPE does not typically provide insulation from shock. In addition, arc flash PPE is limited in the kind of protection it can provide from the pressure wave of the arc blast.

Details of implementing a shock and arc flash PPE program are beyond the scope of this article, but will be addressed in future articles. Suffice it to say that PPE programs designed to protect workers from electrical hazards can be complicated because the worker must protect himself or herself from two different hazards that have very different characteristics and levels of risk depending on the work being performed. The worker must assess the risk of both shock and arc flash, and the risks can vary for each of these hazards.

Summary

Shock and arc flash are vastly different events and are usually independent of each other. Although a shock can trigger an arc flash and vice versa, the two events are usually exclusive of one another. The graphic below summarizes the different characteristics and different PPE requirements of each event.

Electric Shock

Current passing through the human body or across the surface

Frequency

• Much more common than arc flash

Injuries/Risk

• Ventricular fibrillation
• Internal burns
• External burns
• Entry and exit wounds

PPE

• Insulation, usually in the form of voltage-rated rubber gloves and insulated tools

• Other insulating equipment such as mats, blankets, etc. as needed

Arc Flash

A dangerous condition associated with the release of energy caused by an electric arc

Frequency

• Much rarer than shock

Injuries/Risk

• Severe burns over large parts of the body
• Blindness or eye damage from UV Lights
• Hearing damage from high-decibel sound
• Shrapnel wounds from flying debris
• Pressure wave injuries
• Lung blast injuries caused by first breath response

PPE

• Arc-rated clothing (pants, shirt, coveralls)
• Arc-rated face shields
• Arc-rated balaclava
• Arc Flash suits (for > 12 cal/cm2)
• Arc Flash hoods (for >12 cal/cm2)
• Safety glasses
• Hearing protection

In future articles, I’ll go into more detail about each of the hazards. In the meantime, keep this in mind:

Shock and arc flash pose no risk whatsoever if you shut off the power before working on electrical equipment.

Thank you and be safe,
Bobby Lindsey – CESCP
Mitchell & Lindsey – President
M: (502) 836-4217
email: blindsey@mitchellandlindsey.com

Free PPE Poster

Location:

Contact Us:

Connect: